+- TrueBlueArmy Forums (https://forum.truebluearmy.com)
+-- Forum: TBA forums (https://forum.truebluearmy.com/forumdisplay.php?fid=1)
+--- Forum: Play Up Pompey (https://forum.truebluearmy.com/forumdisplay.php?fid=2)
+--- Thread: Stop the Loans (/showthread.php?tid=2508)
Pages:
1
2
Stop the Loans - HotToddy - 18-12-2022
I'm as frustrated as everyone else right now. The team has no character or method of play. I want our own contracted players to play - not loanees from other clubs. We should be developing or improving our own players. Most of our loanees have been mediocre. More to the point, they don't allow me to fully support them as part of our history/journey as they will be moving on at season's end.
RE: Stop the Loans - slayer - 18-12-2022
Bazunu? Carter? Romeo?
I am Cowley out now (ffs) but he has loaned well to be fair
RE: Stop the Loans - HotToddy - 18-12-2022
(18-12-2022, 12:49 AM)scumslayer Wrote: Bazunu? Carter? Romeo?
I am Cowley out now (ffs) but he has loaned well to be fair
Yes, Bazunu and Carter were good players for us. Pity we didn't sign them. My point is they will never be recognised as Pompey players because they were loans.
RE: Stop the Loans - Hammie - 18-12-2022
unless they get us into at least the play offs, then any loan has been a failure.
I can cope with young players making mistakes, as long as they are here long enough for us to benefit from their learning on the job.
If they belong to someone else and we are not in the promotion picture as a result of their being here, then what exactly is the benefit to Pompey?
RE: Stop the Loans - mikey393 - 18-12-2022
The loan system was designed to benefit both clubs & the player.
But what appears to happen is that they are learning their trade at our expense.
If they are really good we can't afford the transfer fee or their wages.
The real problem is that clubs like Pompey don't have a large enough playing budget so couldn't attract enough contract players in the Summer.
Ask yourself, how many players did we get outbid for by mediocre teams including stockport County?
RE: Stop the Loans - Pompeyg100 - 18-12-2022
(18-12-2022, 12:49 AM)scumslayer Wrote: Bazunu? Carter? Romeo?
I am Cowley out now (ffs) but he has loaned well to be fair
And for balance there have been some bad ones or good ones that he simply doesn’t play which I guess makes them bad.
RE: Stop the Loans - Pedalo_menders - 18-12-2022
You can't build a squad with a new nipper in goal every season. Especially when your best defender likes to regularly drop clangers and the other two CB's you have, one is always out injured and the other is a new 1 season recruit.
It's these planning failures that see us where we are. It's a complete mess.
RE: Stop the Loans - Isaac Hunt - 18-12-2022
Loans should be abolished.
Just distorts everything.
Go out and sign your squad and fuck the Premier hoovering clubs
RE: Stop the Loans - 66zoolane - 18-12-2022
(18-12-2022, 12:44 AM)HotToddy Wrote: I'm as frustrated as everyone else right now. The team has no character or method of play. I want our own contracted players to play - not loanees from other clubs. We should be developing or improving our own players. Most of our loanees have been mediocre. More to the point, they don't allow me to fully support them as part of our history/journey as they will be moving on at season's end.
I agree - as good as some loans have been, and others not, they ultimately don't have any agenda but impressing their parent club and fulfilling obligations, with no extended interest in what happens when they're gone.
But I also agree with Isaac's comment that loans should be abolished, because unless that happens across the board, without loans we'd be lacking higher-league class against clubs that use them.
RE: Stop the Loans - HotToddy - 18-12-2022
(18-12-2022, 08:04 PM)66zoolane Wrote:(18-12-2022, 12:44 AM)HotToddy Wrote: I'm as frustrated as everyone else right now. The team has no character or method of play. I want our own contracted players to play - not loanees from other clubs. We should be developing or improving our own players. Most of our loanees have been mediocre. More to the point, they don't allow me to fully support them as part of our history/journey as they will be moving on at season's end.
I agree - as good as some loans have been, and others not, they ultimately don't have any agenda but impressing their parent club and fulfilling obligations, with no extended interest in what happens when they're gone.
But I also agree with Isaac's comment that loans should be abolished, because unless that happens across the board, without loans we'd be lacking higher-league class against clubs that use them.
Zoo: I agree with you. But let's look at the "higher-league class" you think we'd be lacking without our loans:
Griffiths - I'd rather we developed Josh Oluwayemi. From what I've seen, he is just as good.
Koroma - Supposedly worth 2M euros - you are having a laugh! I'm not particularly a Curtis fan, but Koroma is no upgrade.
Scarlett - One diving header, otherwise no end product. Why do we play him? Reminds me of Hirst but without the talent.
Pigott - Good loan if we make Ipswich an offer in January. (500K euros).
Dale - Headless chicken. Rather we developed Reeko as a right winger.
Not sure if I've forgotten anyone.
RE: Stop the Loans - Hammie - 18-12-2022
that seems to sum it up for me.
At least Hughes seems to agree from his recent comments.
Hopefully he also agrees with the general feeling about our managers
RE: Stop the Loans - dsmg - 18-12-2022
Isn’t Reeco very left footed to be a right winger?
RE: Stop the Loans - HotToddy - 20-12-2022
(18-12-2022, 10:56 PM)dsmg Wrote: Isn’t Reeco very left footed to be a right winger?
Not sure about being very left footed, but yes he is left footed. I seem to recall him being effective when playing centrally or on the right though.
RE: Stop the Loans - Cunninglinguist - 20-12-2022
You seem to recall??
Chuckle.
HT for manager.
RE: Stop the Loans - WheresDave - 20-12-2022
(20-12-2022, 01:59 AM)HotToddy Wrote:(18-12-2022, 10:56 PM)dsmg Wrote: Isn’t Reeco very left footed to be a right winger?
Not sure about being very left footed, but yes he is left footed. I seem to recall him being effective when playing centrally or on the right though.
I know its xmas but you should off the drink a bit mush
RE: Stop the Loans - Hammie - 20-12-2022
Isn't it a fact that we play wingers on the wrong wing foot wise, or is there another reason why they ALL cut inside almost all of the time.
Curtis, cut in
Koroma, not a winger so goes central
Dale seems to spend most of his energy running across the pitch often at an angle towards his own goal.
RE: Stop the Loans - HotToddy - 20-12-2022
(20-12-2022, 08:06 AM)Cunninglinguist Wrote: You seem to recall??
Chuckle.
HT for manager.
Stop being such an ass. It's a figure of speech. But thanks for the manager recommendation
RE: Stop the Loans - Cunninglinguist - 21-12-2022
(20-12-2022, 10:37 PM)HotToddy Wrote:It really isn’t.(20-12-2022, 08:06 AM)Cunninglinguist Wrote: You seem to recall??
Chuckle.
HT for manager.
Stop being such an ass. It's a figure of speech. But thanks for the manager recommendation
Just a figure of speech.
RE: Stop the Loans - bluetagagain - 21-12-2022
Back to the OP. Payday loans were always shit. Glad they’ve gone bust- parasites.
RE: Stop the Loans - Northstander - 21-12-2022
Just one example I read that Chelsea have 20 players out on loan (Crazy) including the MK Keeper we didn't test enough Saturday.
RE: Stop the Loans - dsmg - 21-12-2022
The rich get richer, the poor get poorer
RE: Stop the Loans - Isaac Hunt - 21-12-2022
Bring back reserves leagues.
RE: Stop the Loans - Hammie - 21-12-2022
(21-12-2022, 12:44 PM)dsmg Wrote: The rich get richer, the poor get poorer
the clear and long term reason for the Prem.
Why I would ahve been delighted to see the Euro league happen and the rich handful disappear into the sunset
RE: Stop the Loans - Cunninglinguist - 21-12-2022
I’d ideally like to see the Sky money pulled from the Premier league. It all went downhill with the greed.
RE: Stop the Loans - slayer - 21-12-2022
Need to introduce a salary cap in step with ground capacity.
Needs to treat BIKs as salary in cash terms.
When a top player is capped to a top salary, we solve the problem.
If a player wants to go to a different league to play, let them.
If the FA start, Ligue 1, the Bundesliga, La Liga and ultimately UEFA will follow, followed in turn by FIFA.
Within a decade, problem solved.