+- TrueBlueArmy Forums (https://forum.truebluearmy.com)
+-- Forum: TBA forums (https://forum.truebluearmy.com/forumdisplay.php?fid=1)
+--- Forum: Play Up Pompey (https://forum.truebluearmy.com/forumdisplay.php?fid=2)
+--- Thread: Who in their right mind… (/showthread.php?tid=2628)
Pages:
1
2
Who in their right mind… - blueinbrum3 - 14-01-2023
would want the job of Head Coach at Fratton Park? Their only target will be to avoid relegation and that is looking more and more a possibility with each passing game. The pressure on them is going to be intense from day one. Who of the current candidates looks most likely able to withstand the pressure and more importantly will they still be a candidate by the end of today? Over the years we’ve suffered some poor teams but this current squad defies description. Major squad rebuild needed and already half way through current transfer window. How have Pompey arrived at this utterly ridiculous situation?
RE: Who in their right mind… - ForeverPompey - 14-01-2023
Totally agree. From Clarke, Burgess, Lowe at al to this rabble in 4 easy years.
RE: Who in their right mind… - Ain’t got a Danny - 14-01-2023
Someone with a bit of know how and charisma is what’s needed. And a willingness to tell Hughes to keep out of his way.
RE: Who in their right mind… - Daniel - 14-01-2023
Their wage demands have gone up dramatically!! I would of quite liked manning but it would be so hard for a inexperienced manager to take this on. Going to have to go all out and spend the money on wilder give him what he wants and the players he needs to build on next season.
RE: Who in their right mind… - suffolkpompey - 14-01-2023
(14-01-2023, 04:47 PM)ForeverPompey Wrote: Totally agree. From Clarke, Burgess, Lowe at al to this rabble in 4 easy years.
And who was the manager for the majority of those 4 years.
RE: Who in their right mind… - Ain’t got a Danny - 14-01-2023
Pompey managers in recent years seem intimidated by the expectation.
RE: Who in their right mind… - Northstander - 14-01-2023
(14-01-2023, 04:47 PM)ForeverPompey Wrote: Totally agree. From Clarke, Burgess, Lowe at al to this rabble in 4 easy years.
Ben Thompson too
RE: Who in their right mind… - Pompeyg100 - 14-01-2023
(14-01-2023, 04:46 PM)blueinbrum3 Wrote: would want the job of Head Coach at Fratton Park? Their only target will be to avoid relegation and that is looking more and more a possibility with each passing game. The pressure on them is going to be intense from day one. Who of the current candidates looks most likely able to withstand the pressure and more importantly will they still be a candidate by the end of today? Over the years we’ve suffered some poor teams but this current squad defies description. Major squad rebuild needed and already half way through current transfer window. How have Pompey arrived at this utterly ridiculous situation?
I agree, the person coming in is under a massive amount of pressure based on team performance and recent results. It’s a shambles and i don’t see a head coach type being the person we need right now.
Get a manager in who has full control until the end of the season whilst looking for a head coach who hopefully has a better place to start.
RE: Who in their right mind… - Kingo - 14-01-2023
The more it goes on, the more I think getting Colin Wanker in for the rest of the season is not such a bad idea. He might just ruffle a few feathers and drag the club out of it's current comatose state.
RE: Who in their right mind… - Hammie - 14-01-2023
If we are down to the bare bones, its an ideal time for Harry to arrive
RE: Who in their right mind… - Northstander - 14-01-2023
(14-01-2023, 07:01 PM)Kingo Wrote: The more it goes on, the more I think getting Colin Wanker in for the rest of the season is not such a bad idea. He might just ruffle a few feathers and drag the club out of it's current comatose state.
Would make a lot of sense to me if the Eisners would pay for him, something needs to be done
RE: Who in their right mind… - Kingo - 14-01-2023
Perhaps a double act? Would at least be a laugh.
RE: Who in their right mind… - Smirnoffexpress - 14-01-2023
(14-01-2023, 04:46 PM)blueinbrum3 Wrote: would want the job of Head Coach at Fratton Park? Their only target will be to avoid relegation and that is looking more and more a possibility with each passing game. The pressure on them is going to be intense from day one. Who of the current candidates looks most likely able to withstand the pressure and more importantly will they still be a candidate by the end of today? Over the years we’ve suffered some poor teams but this current squad defies description. Major squad rebuild needed and already half way through current transfer window. How have Pompey arrived at this utterly ridiculous situation“ major re build” AKA just about a new team. Look at the reason for that, not enough contracted players and not enough contracted players with quality. Shopping in the bargain basement, sifting through the league one and lower cast offs and supplementing them with loanees was never going to work and rarely would. If that is all that the Eisners can provide then its best that they fuck off.
RE: Who in their right mind… - Slagger - 14-01-2023
(14-01-2023, 07:01 PM)Kingo Wrote: The more it goes on, the more I think getting Colin Wanker in for the rest of the season is not such a bad idea. He might just ruffle a few feathers and drag the club out of it's current comatose state.
Yep Colin Wanker is the only manager I can think of who has the bollocks for what is lurching towards a relegation battle.
RE: Who in their right mind… - DeepBlue - 14-01-2023
Hard to believe that it is only 7 days since a battling perfomance at Tottenham had everyone saying we were in a good place for a new manager to take over.
RE: Who in their right mind… - Smirnoffexpress - 14-01-2023
What manager of any consequence would want the job as it stands. A director of football picking players for you, a restricted budget that’s already been spent and a squad that are failing. Hardly enticing for any established manager, leaving us left with the desperate and or the cheap.
Poundland Pompey!
RE: Who in their right mind… - 66zoolane - 14-01-2023
(14-01-2023, 07:15 PM)DeepBlue Wrote: Hard to believe that it is only 7 days since a battling perfomance at Tottenham had everyone saying we were in a good place for a new manager to take over.
There's that way of looking at it but also possibly, giving everything when you're in the shop window. Hope it was the former.
RE: Who in their right mind… - Pompeyg100 - 14-01-2023
(14-01-2023, 07:21 PM)Smirnoffexpress Wrote: What manager of any consequence would want the job as it stands. A director of football picking players for you, a restricted budget that’s already been spent and a squad that are failing. Hardly enticing for any established manager, leaving us left with the desperate and or the cheap.
Poundland Pompey!
We aren’t looking for an established manager though, you’d think after 2 weeks you might have heard this. It’s had to be stated on here about 15 times a day.
It’s a head coach position so we are looking for a coach to step up in to a head coach role, like Ipswich.
RE: Who in their right mind… - Kingo - 14-01-2023
Perhaps they've got a good dof
RE: Who in their right mind… - Jezzer - 14-01-2023
(14-01-2023, 07:21 PM)Smirnoffexpress Wrote: What manager of any consequence would want the job as it stands. A director of football picking players for you, a restricted budget that’s already been spent and a squad that are failing. Hardly enticing for any established manager, leaving us left with the desperate and or the cheap.The answer is a desperate one as you say. Can you see someone like Wilder bowing to the superior knowledge of a 34 year old DOF who apparently discovered a couple of nippers while at Forest Green and also scouted for Tamworth? Me neither.
Poundland
RE: Who in their right mind… - foxleyblue - 15-01-2023
(14-01-2023, 06:26 PM)Pompeyg100 Wrote:(14-01-2023, 04:46 PM)blueinbrum3 Wrote: would want the job of Head Coach at Fratton Park? Their only target will be to avoid relegation and that is looking more and more a possibility with each passing game. The pressure on them is going to be intense from day one. Who of the current candidates looks most likely able to withstand the pressure and more importantly will they still be a candidate by the end of today? Over the years we’ve suffered some poor teams but this current squad defies description. Major squad rebuild needed and already half way through current transfer window. How have Pompey arrived at this utterly ridiculous situation?
I agree, the person coming in is under a massive amount of pressure based on team performance and recent results. It’s a shambles and i don’t see a head coach type being the person we need right now.
Get a manager in who has full control until the end of the season whilst looking for a head coach who hopefully has a better place to start.
Harry?
RE: Who in their right mind… - Farjam - 15-01-2023
Wilder....no brainer
Forget the inexperienced and unproven
RE: Who in their right mind… - Gerry Hatrick - 15-01-2023
(14-01-2023, 11:41 PM)Jezzer Wrote:(14-01-2023, 07:21 PM)Smirnoffexpress Wrote: What manager of any consequence would want the job as it stands. A director of football picking players for you, a restricted budget that’s already been spent and a squad that are failing. Hardly enticing for any established manager, leaving us left with the desperate and or the cheap.The answer is a desperate one as you say. Can you see someone like Wilder bowing to the superior knowledge of a 34 year old DOF who apparently discovered a couple of nippers while at Forest Green and also scouted for Tamworth? Me neither.
Poundland
No, but....
.....isn't that the whole point of a job interview? Wilder will know about the DoF situation here and if he gets interviewed it shows that he is willing to negotiate around that part - if the club are. There is still the hope that Wilder can thrash out a deal with the club about the extent of Hughes' influence and one that Hughes himself is on board with. For example, while Hughes could recommend signings, Wilder could insist on the final decision on all transfers.
But concern with this DoF relationship is a red herring when we witness the kind of shambolic performance we saw yesterday. Most of these players had us top of the league in September. You cannot say someone like Marlon Pack wouldn't give his right arm to bring success to his hometown club. It is 80% about coaching and man management, not signings. It is about getting inside the heads of these players and finding what makes them tick individually and collectively. Who can explain why defenders, coached in fitness and tactics every week, end up as bemused spectators when danger threatens like rabbits gazing into the headlights on an on-coming car.
What will get us out of this downward spiral is a great motivator and communicator. Great coaches don't always make great managers. Yes, you can be pedantic and say that we are touting for a Head Coach, not a 'manager' but in addition to being tactically astute, that person will undoubtedly need to manage people.
As I write, I feel I am describing Harry Redknapp. If we can find a way for Chris Wilder to work with Hughes, he could our next Harry.
RE: Who in their right mind… - Smirnoffexpress - 15-01-2023
(14-01-2023, 11:41 PM)Jezzer Wrote:(14-01-2023, 07:21 PM)Smirnoffexpress Wrote: What manager of any consequence would want the job as it stands. A director of football picking players for you, a restricted budget that’s already been spent and a squad that are failing. Hardly enticing for any established manager, leaving us left with the desperate and or the cheap.The answer is a desperate one as you say. Can you see someone like Wilder bowing to the superior knowledge of a 34 year old DOF who apparently discovered a couple of nippers while at Forest Green and also scouted for Tamworth? Me neither.
Poundland
What sort of job is “director of football” at our level? If it’s merely talent spotting then just about every fan in the stands could do it!
RE: Who in their right mind… - Roybatty - 15-01-2023
(15-01-2023, 10:40 AM)Smirnoffexpress Wrote:It's just job creation,gives the chief executive less to do(14-01-2023, 11:41 PM)Jezzer Wrote:(14-01-2023, 07:21 PM)Smirnoffexpress Wrote: What manager of any consequence would want the job as it stands. A director of football picking players for you, a restricted budget that’s already been spent and a squad that are failing. Hardly enticing for any established manager, leaving us left with the desperate and or the cheap.The answer is a desperate one as you say. Can you see someone like Wilder bowing to the superior knowledge of a 34 year old DOF who apparently discovered a couple of nippers while at Forest Green and also scouted for Tamworth? Me neither.
Poundland
What sort of job is “director of football” at our level? If it’s merely talent spotting then just about every fan in the stands could do it!